On November 17, The Real Deal reported that a well known multifamily syndicator faces foreclosure on a $365.6 million loan. The loan, taken out in 2022, is tied to five apartment properties in Texas and Georgia with nearly 1,700 units. The same report said loans facing foreclosure across the Texas Triangle topped $1 billion in October, mostly on buildings that syndicators bought. Each filing marks a commercial real estate loan workout that never happened or did not hold. For sponsors still talking to their lenders, the question is what a workout can achieve and what it asks of investors.
A loan workout is any negotiated change to a loan after the borrower can no longer meet its terms. It runs from a short extension to a handover of the property. Lenders often prefer one to foreclosure, so a sponsor usually has more room than a default notice suggests. How a workout ends depends less on the lender's patience than on early choices about investors, the operating agreement and tax. Those choices belong in the same plan a sponsor uses to raise capital for a real estate syndication, because the investors who funded the deal will vote on, pay for or be taxed on the result.
Why Lenders Agree to a Commercial Real Estate Loan Workout
Foreclosure is slow and expensive, and it leaves the lender owning a building it must run or sell. Federal bank regulators acknowledged this in a policy statement issued on June 29, 2023 by the Federal Reserve, the FDIC, the NCUA and the OCC. It says accommodations and workouts “are often in the best interest of financial institutions and their borrowers.” The statement replaced guidance from 2009 and added a section on short term accommodations, such as deferred payments. It sets expectations for banks, not rights for borrowers, so a sponsor still earns each concession with data and a credible plan.
Lenders have used that room. Speaking to Multifamily Dive in January 2026, CAPREIT chief executive Andrew Kadish said lenders “would rather just put it off for another 12 months” than take properties back. That patience has limits. A lender that has extended once usually asks for more the second time, such as a paydown, fresh reserves or a stronger guaranty. A loan held in a CMBS pool is harder still, because the special servicer acts for bondholders and must justify any change to them.
Workout Options From Extension to Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure
Workouts fall along a range. At the mild end sits an extension, which buys time on the existing terms or close to them. Forbearance is the lender's agreement not to enforce its remedies for a set period while the borrower cures, sells or refinances. A loan modification changes the terms themselves, such as the rate, amortization or maturity date. Lenders usually ask for a paydown, new reserves or a sweep of property cash flow in return. A discounted payoff lets the borrower retire the loan for less than its balance, typically with money from a sale or a new lender.
At the far end, the sponsor gives up the property. In a deed in lieu of foreclosure, the borrower transfers title to the lender by agreement. That is faster and quieter than a court or trustee sale, and it can settle claims against the borrower. Foreclosure is the lender's own remedy under state law. On a nonrecourse loan it generally ends the lender's claim, apart from the carve outs in the guaranty. Those carve outs, explained in what a bad boy guarantee asks of sponsors, set the principals' personal exposure if talks fail, so they shape the sponsor's position from the first call.
The Equity Decision Behind Every Workout
Almost every option that keeps the property needs new money. A paydown, a replacement rate cap or a reserve top up has to come from somewhere. In a syndication that usually means a capital call, preferred equity or a recapitalization with a new partner. The Real Deal's report shows how this unfolds. The same syndicator paused distributions on its first value add fund in 2023, citing the cost of its interest rate caps, and later called 20 percent of investors' initial investment.
The operating agreement sets the limits on that money. It says whether the manager may modify debt alone or needs a member vote, whether members who skip a capital call are diluted, and whether new equity may rank ahead of existing classes. A sponsor that reads those terms first knows which offers it can accept on the spot and which need approval. Investors who learn of a default from the news are also less likely to fund the plan that follows. The timing of investor updates is therefore part of the workout itself.
The Tax Result Investors Will See on Their K-1s
Each route produces a different tax result, and investors see it on Schedule K-1 the following spring, often with no cash to pay the tax. The IRS treats a foreclosure or deed in lieu as a disposition of the property. Under IRS Topic 432, when the debt is nonrecourse the amount realized is “the entire amount of the nonrecourse debt.” That holds even when the property is worth less. A partnership that hands back a building whose loan exceeds its tax basis can allocate a gain with nothing to distribute.
A modification or discounted payoff that forgives part of the balance works differently. The forgiven amount is generally cancellation of debt income, which the lender reports on Form 1099-C. Under Section 108(d)(6) of the Internal Revenue Code, the exclusions for that income, including the one for qualified real property business indebtedness, are “applied at the partner level.” Two investors in the same deal can therefore face different results. Investors abroad raise withholding and filing questions of their own. A sponsor that plans the K-1 calendar with its administrator, as the guide to real estate fund administration describes, can warn investors months before the forms arrive.
What Sponsors Can Do Before a Loan Comes Due
The most useful work happens well before a maturity date or a missed payment, while the sponsor still controls the timing. These steps work best in order, because each one informs the next.
- Read the loan documents and the guaranty with counsel, to confirm extension rights, cure periods and the acts that trigger personal liability.
- Read the operating agreement for the approvals a modification, capital call or new equity class would need.
- Build the case for the lender on current rent rolls, expenses and a business plan that reaches a refinancing or a sale.
- Ask the tax advisor to model each option, from extension to deed in lieu, at the partner level.
- Tell investors what is happening, what the options are and when they will hear more, before a lender deadline forces the conversation.
Raveum offers sponsors an investment management platform, fund administration, a global raise track under Regulation S and an operating partnership for selected sponsors. Sponsors keep their investor relationships, their property and their business plan, while investor records and reporting sit in one place. See how the Raveum Sponsor Program works.
Where a Workout Is Really Decided
This week's foreclosure will be read as a story about one portfolio and one lender. It also shows that the terms of a commercial real estate loan workout are set long before anyone signs a forbearance agreement. They are set in the operating agreement, the guaranty and the trust a sponsor has kept with its investors. Lenders will often extend or modify rather than take a building back, but they do so for a sponsor with a plan its investors can fund and its tax advisors have priced. A sponsor that treats a workout as a second raise, run with the discipline in the guide to raising capital for a real estate syndication, keeps the widest choice of outcomes when the loan comes due.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is a Commercial Real Estate Loan Workout?
A commercial real estate loan workout is a negotiated change to a loan after the borrower cannot meet its terms. It can be an extension, forbearance, a modification of the rate or maturity, a discounted payoff or a deed in lieu of foreclosure. Lenders often prefer a workout to foreclosure because taking back a property is slow and costly, but most concessions require new money or new protections.
What Is the Difference Between Forbearance and a Loan Modification?
Forbearance is the lender's agreement not to enforce its remedies for a set period while the borrower cures a default, sells or refinances, and the loan terms stay the same. A loan modification changes the terms themselves, such as the interest rate, amortization or maturity date, and usually comes with a principal paydown, new reserves or a sweep of property cash flow.
How Does a Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure Differ From Foreclosure?
In a deed in lieu, the borrower hands title to the lender by agreement, which is usually faster and cheaper than a foreclosure run under state law. The agreement can settle claims against the borrower and guarantors, so its wording matters. In a foreclosure the lender enforces its remedy without the borrower's cooperation. For tax purposes, the IRS treats both as a disposition of the property.
Do Investors Owe Tax When a Syndication Property Is Handed Back?
They can. On a nonrecourse loan, the IRS counts the full loan balance as the amount realized, so a partnership can allocate a gain to investors even when no cash is distributed. If part of a loan is forgiven instead, investors may receive cancellation of debt income, and Section 108 applies its exclusions at the partner level. Each investor should check the result with a tax advisor.
Can a Sponsor Be Personally Liable on a Nonrecourse Loan?
Yes, in defined cases. Most nonrecourse commercial loans carry a guaranty with carve outs, often called bad boy provisions, that make the guarantor liable for losses or for the full debt if certain acts occur, such as a voluntary bankruptcy filing or a transfer the lender has not approved. The exact wording controls, so counsel should read the guaranty before any workout talks begin.
When Should a Sponsor Bring In Counsel During a Loan Workout?
Before the first conversation with the lender. Counsel can confirm what the loan documents and guaranty allow, what approvals the operating agreement requires before the manager accepts new terms or calls capital, and what investors must be told. Many lenders also ask for a prenegotiation letter that sets the ground rules for talks, and counsel should read it before the sponsor signs.
This article is for general education only and is not legal, tax or investment advice. Securities and tax rules change and depend on each sponsor's facts, so work with qualified securities counsel and tax advisors before launching an offering. Real estate investments involve risk, including loss of capital, illiquidity and changes in property values. Offerings on Raveum are available to eligible investors only and are not open to the general public.

